4 short-lived Netflix shows that deserved way more seasons than they got

Netflix has no shortage of ambitious original series, but it also has a habit of cutting them off just as they start to find their rhythm. Some shows arrive with strong concepts, passionate fanbases, and clear long-term storytelling potential only to be canceled before their worlds can fully expand.

The result is a growing list of unfinished stories that still linger in conversation long after their final episodes aired. Below, we shared four short-lived Netflix shows that many fans believe deserved far more seasons than they were given!

I Am Not Okay with This (2020)

I Am Not Okay With This starts off feeling like a pretty familiar teen drama. There are the awkward high school moments, friendship drama, crushes that go nowhere, and the general chaos of being a teenager who doesn’t really feel like they fit anywhere.

But underneath all of that is Sydney Novak, a girl dealing with grief she doesn’t fully understand and emotions she definitely can’t control. Her father’s suicide hangs over her life in a quiet, constant way. It's never overly dramatic. It's just… there. Then things start to shift.

When Sydney gets overwhelmed with emotions, the world around her reacts. Objects move, things break, and she has no idea why. What’s interesting is that the show never treats her powers like a superhero upgrade. It feels more like a pressure valve for everything she’s holding inside. The more she struggles emotionally, the more dangerous things become around her.

By the end of the first season, it’s clear the story is just getting started. But sadly, it just stops there. Netflix canceled the series before the second season even got a proper chance to exist, which really hurt fans because the streaming giant had initially renewed the black comedy series. Why was I Am Not Okay With This canceled after only one installment? The cancellation reportedly came down to COVID-19-related production disruptions. What a shame!

Warrior Nun (2020-2022)

Warrior Nun is one of those shows that sounds completely unhinged when you first explain it until you actually watch it.

Now, here's the gist. A girl wakes up in a morgue. She’s dead, except she isn’t anymore. Something called the Halo has been placed inside her, and now she’s suddenly part of an ancient order of warrior nuns who fight demons. It’s wild, but it works because at the center of it all is Ava. Ava is someone who never asked for any of this and is just trying to figure out what kind of life she’s even supposed to be living.

The show is less about “good vs evil” and more about control. Everyone around Ava seems to have a plan for her. A purpose or a role she’s supposed to fill. And she spends most of the series quietly pushing back against that.

By season 2, the world has expanded in a big way. The mythology gets deeper, the stakes get higher, and the emotional connections between characters start to really land. So when Netflix canceled it after just two installments in 2022, it didn’t feel like a clean ending. It felt like the story had just hit its stride.

The reaction from fans was immediate and loud, and honestly, understandable. It’s one of those cancellations where you can almost see the shape of what a third season would’ve been, even if it never got made.

First Kill (2022)

First Kill is basically what happens when you take a classic “enemies to lovers” story and give it fangs. Literally!

Juliette is a vampire from a powerful family with a long legacy of violence. Calliope is a monster hunter raised to kill creatures like Juliette. Both of them are expected to step into roles they didn’t exactly choose, but everyone around them acts like it’s inevitable. Then they meet, and instead of trying to kill each other, they fall for each other.

That’s really the heart of the show. However, it’s not just romance. It’s also about the feeling of being trapped between who you’re supposed to be and who you actually are. Both girls are carrying family pressure, expectations, and traditions that feel too heavy to question until they do. The problem is, the world around them doesn’t exactly allow for compromise.

The show builds toward something much bigger, like family conflict, supernatural politics, and a love story that was clearly meant to be tested over multiple seasons. But Netflix canceled it after just one installment in 2022, citing low audience retention despite a strong initial debut. So instead of watching Cal and Juliette's relationship grow, be tested, and evolve, we’re left right at the beginning of it all.

Lockwood & Co. (2023)

There’s something instantly comforting about Lockwood & Co. even though, technically, it’s about ghosts.

In this version of London, ghosts are everywhere. They're not rare nor mysterious. They're just part of everyday life. The catch is that only teenagers can see them clearly enough to fight them, which means the entire ghost-hunting industry is basically run by kids. At the center of it all are Lockwood, George, and Lucy. They're just three teens running a tiny independent agency trying to survive in a world dominated by massive corporate ghost-hunting firms.

What makes the show work isn’t just the supernatural stuff. It’s the way these three slowly start to feel like a team. Not in a “we’re coworkers” way, but in a “we’ve seen things together that no one else would believe” way. And just as the show starts opening up its bigger mysteries, it gets canceled after one season.

Despite strong reviews and a loyal fanbase, Netflix decided not to move forward with a second installment. Why? Its cancellation was reportedly due to the show's declining viewership numbers, which makes it even more frustrating because you could just feel how much bigger the story was supposed to become.

All four of these canceled Netflix shows can be streamed right now.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow