Skip to main content

The 5 best Christmasy moments in Guarding Stars

Relive the best Christmassy moments from Netflix’s Guarding Stars, starring Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki—from the rodeo kiss cam to the holiday proposal.
ByLaura Nowak
Guarding Stars. Leighton Meester as Hannah in Guarding Stars.
Guarding Stars. Leighton Meester as Hannah in Guarding Stars. | Courtesy of Netflix

Christmas came early this year when Guarding Stars premiered. Even though Jared Padalecki and Leighton Meester both appeared on The CW for years, they never appeared opposite each other. But their chemistry may melt the snow on Guarding Stars.

Meester portrays Hannah Brooks, a tough-as-nails bodyguard who's hired to pose as Jack Stapleton's girlfriend at his family's snowy Montana ranch. Since they both have baggage, including that she doesn't even know his star status, holiday cheer will get a little complicated. Guarding Stars is a cozy, festive rom-com overflowing with small-town warmth, flirtatious banter, and undeniable chemistry. From chaotic snow days to quiet acoustic evenings, these Christmassy moments make the movie an instant holiday favorite.

The Family Dinner Confession

Sitting around the dinner table with Jack's family, the fake-dating act takes a surprisingly sweet turn when Jack shares how he and Hannah first met. He needed to think quickly and pretended he needed help with his security system, claiming he kept breaking it so she'd come back over and get stuck in the red lasers.

Instead of sticking to a rehearsed Hollywood script, he warmly admits that he thought she was cute even when she was annoyed with him. It's a charming, unscripted-feeling beat that catches Hannah completely off guard and gives the audience an early glimpse at how deeply he's already falling for her.

 Leighton Meester as Hannah and Jared Padalecki as Jack in Guarding Stars.
Guarding Stars. (L-R) Leighton Meester as Hannah and Jared Padalecki as Jack in Guarding Stars. | Courtesy of Netflix

The Snowball Fight

Nothing breaks the ice quite like  a snowball fight to ease the tension. Jack knows Hannah is angry that he went out without her protection, so he suggests they throw snowballs to let out her aggression. He senses his family watching their every move, so he puts on a fun show for them, and a few snowballs quickly turn into an all-out snowball fight, stripping away Hannah's serious bodyguard exterior and Jack's movie-star polish.

The scene hits rom-com perfection when the tussle ends with the two of them landing right on top of each other in the snow, laughing and lingering just a second too long to pretend it's all strictly business. Playing Ava Max's "I Wish" during this scene added to the rom-com flair, as did Jack's niece and nephew pelting him with snowballs to help Hannah.

The Mistletoe Rodeo Kiss Cam

Surrounded by cheering locals and festive lights at the town rodeo, Jack and Hannah face their biggest test yet when the Mistletoe Kiss Cam locks onto them. Hannah is nearly as terrified of facing their feelings as she is of Jack's stalker finding him. They have nowhere to hide, and the entire town is watching and cheering, including Jack's enthusiastic family. The kiss they share blurs the line between putting on a show and giving in to real feelings. The lingering looks afterward make it clear that neither of them is just acting anymore, even if they don't want to admit it yet.

Jared Padalecki as Jack and Leighton Meester as Hannah in Guarding Stars.
Guarding Stars. (L-R) Jared Padalecki as Jack and Leighton Meester as Hannah in Guarding Stars. | Courtesy of Netflix

Decorating the Tree to Jack's Guitar

Amid the holiday hustle and fake-relationship stress, the film slows down for one of its coziest, most grounded moments. Jack hadn't been home in ages because of family issues. Still, he returned because his mother, Connie (Andie MacDowell), needed him.

As Jack sits back and strums softly on his guitar, the family gathers around to decorate the Christmas tree together. Connie realizes Hannah makes her son happy, and Hannah experiences the room's easy warmth, offering a quiet, emotional realization of what a real home and belonging actually feel like.

 Zoe Kosovic, Henrik Bosovich, Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki in Guarding Stars.
Guarding Stars. (L-R) Zoe Kosovic as Clementine, Henrik Bosovich as Wyatt, Leighton Meester as Hannah and Jared Padalecki as Jack in Guarding Stars. | Chris Large/Netflix

The Christmas Proposal

Everything builds toward a heartwarming holiday finale when the fake romance finally becomes the real thing. Jack doesn't realize how much he loves Hannah until after she leaves. It wouldn't be a rom-com without a holiday proposal, and Jack proposes in almost the way he asked Hannah to be his fake girlfriend.

Only this time, they're surrounded by the magic of Christmas and his family as Jack asks Hannah to be his—for real this time. It’s the ultimate festive payoff, trading Hollywood glitz for a sincere, snow-dusted promise of a future together.

Guarding Stars is streaming now on Netflix.

Add us as a preferred source on Google